Skip to content

Article · money · salary

1099 vs W2: What Each Really Pays After Tax

Dominic Roworth

By · Founder and editor

Published 18 November 2026

A self-employed worker seen from behind at a kitchen table in morning light, working on a laptop beside paperwork, a calculator, a phone and a mug of coffee, illustrating 1099 vs W-2 take-home pay

On the same pay, a 1099 contractor keeps a little less than a W-2 employee, but far less goes to tax than most comparisons claim. On $100,000 in 2026, a single filer in Texas keeps $79,180 as an employee and $77,635 as a contractor: the contractor’s tax bill is only $1,545 higher, because two deductions cancel most of the employer’s half of Social Security and Medicare. The bigger gap is what an employer pays on top of the salary. A full-time private-sector employee gets insurance and retirement contributions worth $6.52 an hour worked and paid time off worth $4.40 an hour (Bureau of Labor Statistics, June 2026). Count those, and a contract has to pay about 30% to 35% more per hour than a W-2 job to leave you as well off.

The tax figures below come from the same 2026 engine as our 1099 tax calculator, and the benefit costs from BLS’s Employer Costs for Employee Compensation survey. Every example is a single filer with the standard deduction and no other income.

The key figures

Figure (2026)AmountSource
Self-employment tax15.3% (12.4% Social Security, 2.9% Medicare) on 92.35% of net profitIRS, Schedule SE
Employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare (W-2)7.65%, matched by the employerIRS, Topic 751
Social Security wage base$184,500IRS, Topic 751
Self-employment tax you can deduct from incomeHalfIRS, Schedule SE
Qualified business income (QBI) deductionUp to 20%, limited to 20% of taxable incomeIRS; section 199A, made permanent by Public Law 119-21
Standard deduction, single$16,100IRS, Rev. Proc. 2025-32
Form 1099-NEC reporting threshold$2,000 (it was $600 before 2026)IRS
Full-time private-sector pay per hour worked: wages, paid leave and supplemental pay$43.72BLS, ECEC, June 2026
Employer insurance and retirement per hour worked$6.52 ($4.58 + $1.94)BLS, ECEC, June 2026

How much more tax does a 1099 contractor pay?

Take $100,000 earned in Texas, which has no state income tax.

As a W-2 employee, you pay $13,170 of federal income tax, $6,200 of Social Security and $1,450 of Medicare: $20,820 in all, leaving $79,180. Your employer pays another $7,650 of Social Security and Medicare that never shows on your pay stub.

As a contractor with $100,000 of profit:

  1. Self-employment tax is worked out on 92.35% of profit, $92,350: 12.4% for Social Security ($11,451.40) and 2.9% for Medicare ($2,678.15), so $14,129.55. That’s both halves, the employee’s and the employer’s.
  2. Half of it, $7,064.78, comes off your income, leaving $92,935.22. Less the $16,100 standard deduction, that’s $76,835.22.
  3. The QBI deduction takes off a further 20%, here limited to 20% of taxable income: $15,367.04. Taxable income is $61,468.18 and federal income tax $8,235.
  4. Total tax $22,364.55, leaving $77,635.45.

So the contractor pays $6,480 more in Social Security and Medicare but $4,935 less in income tax: $1,545 more in all. Here is the same comparison at four levels of pay:

Pay (Texas)W-2 tax1099 taxExtra tax as 1099
$50,000$7,645$9,732$2,087
$75,000$13,408$15,495$2,087
$100,000$20,820$22,365$1,545
$150,000$36,209$37,608$1,399

To keep the same take-home as those four salaries, a contractor needs $52,713, $77,713, $102,222 and $152,012 of profit: 5.4% more at $50,000, falling to 1.3% more at $150,000. The gap shrinks as pay rises because the QBI deduction is worth more at higher tax rates. In states with an income tax it shrinks further, because the deductible half of self-employment tax also lowers the state tax in most states. On $100,000 the extra tax is $888 in California and $1,128 in New York.

Why most 1099 vs W-2 comparisons overstate the tax gap

The usual shortcut is “15.3% instead of 7.65%”, which on $100,000 would mean $7,650 more tax. It leaves out the 92.35% rule above and two things the tax return gives back:

  • Half of self-employment tax is deductible from income, which is how the law treats the “employer” half you pay yourself.
  • The QBI deduction lets most sole proprietors take up to 20% of their business income off their taxable income. It was due to end after 2025; Public Law 119-21, signed on 4 July 2025, made it permanent.

The QBI deduction has limits. Above $201,750 of taxable income (single, 2026), a “specified service” business such as health, law, accounting or consulting starts to lose it, and loses it completely at $276,750. Our calculator assumes no QBI deduction above the threshold, to be safe, so higher earners should run their own numbers.

What a W-2 job pays that never reaches your paycheck

BLS’s Employer Costs for Employee Compensation survey measures what employers spend per hour actually worked. For full-time workers in private industry in June 2026:

Per hour workedCostShare of total
Wages for time worked$36.9768.5%
Paid leave: vacation, holidays, sick and personal days$4.408.1%
Supplemental pay: overtime, shift pay and bonuses$2.354.3%
Insurance: health, life and disability$4.588.5%
Retirement and savings$1.943.6%
Legally required: employer Social Security and Medicare, unemployment insurance, workers’ compensation$3.767.0%
Total compensation$54.00100%

Three things a contract rate has to replace:

  • Insurance and retirement: $6.52 an hour, which is 14.9% on top of the $43.72 that reaches the employee’s pay. At full-time hours that’s about $8,500 a year for insurance and $3,600 for retirement.
  • Paid time off. Paid leave of $4.40 against $36.97 of wages means an average full-time employee is paid for about 11.9% more hours than they work: roughly 1,859 hours worked out of the 2,080 a salary covers. A contractor who takes the same time off can only bill those 1,859 hours.
  • Unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation, which sit in the legally required line. A contractor is covered by neither.

These are averages across every full-time private job. Your employer’s health plan or 401(k) match may be worth more or less: check the offer.

The contract rate that matches a W-2 salary

Put the pieces together: the profit that leaves the same take-home (from the section above), plus 14.9% of the salary for insurance and retirement, spread over 1,859 billable hours. The last column compares that rate with the W-2 hourly rate, the salary divided by 2,080: on $100,000, $63.02 against $48.08.

W-2 salary1099 profit target1099 hourly rateTimes W-2 hourly
$50,000$60,170$32.371.35
$75,000$88,898$47.831.33
$100,000$117,135$63.021.31
$150,000$174,382$93.821.30

That’s profit, so business costs come on top: software, equipment, liability insurance, an accountant. So do the hours you can’t bill, such as finding clients, invoicing and the gaps between contracts. Billing 1,500 hours instead of 1,859, the rate that matches a $100,000 salary rises from $63.02 to $78.09.

The common rule of thumb, that a contract should pay 1.3 to 1.5 times the W-2 rate, holds up. But the reason is mostly benefits and unpaid time, not tax.

When 1099 comes out ahead

  • Business expenses. A contractor’s costs come off profit before both self-employment tax and income tax. Employees generally can’t deduct unreimbursed work expenses on their federal return.
  • Retirement saving. A solo 401(k) lets you defer up to $24,500 in 2026 as the “employee”, and on top of that make “employer” contributions out of profit.
  • Rates and clients. If the market rate for your work is above the break-even rate in the table, contracting pays more, and several clients spread the risk of losing one.
  • Health insurance you buy yourself is deductible from income tax, though not from self-employment tax.

When W-2 is the better deal

  • Health insurance. An employer pays part of the premium, $4.58 an hour worked for all insurance on average, while a contractor pays all of it. And you can’t take the self-employed health insurance deduction for any month you could join an employer’s subsidized plan, including your spouse’s.
  • Paid time off, unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation, as above.
  • Cash flow and paperwork. No one withholds tax for a contractor. If you’ll owe $1,000 or more, you pay estimated tax four times a year: for 2026 income, on April 15, June 15 and September 15, 2026 and January 15, 2027. And a client only has to send a Form 1099-NEC once it pays you $2,000 or more in 2026, but every dollar is taxable whether a form arrives or not.

Contractor or employee: the label isn’t yours to pick

Whether you’re a contractor depends on the working relationship, not on what the contract calls you. The IRS looks at three things:

  1. Behavioral control: does the company control, or have the right to control, what you do and how you do it?
  2. Financial control: does it control the business side of the job, such as how you’re paid, whether expenses are reimbursed and who provides the tools?
  3. The relationship: written contracts, employee-type benefits, whether the work is ongoing and whether it’s a key part of the business.

If you’re unsure, you or the business can ask the IRS to decide with Form SS-8, which takes at least six months. A worker treated as a contractor who should have been an employee can use Form 8919 to pay only the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare. Some states are stricter: California’s ABC test starts from the assumption that every worker is an employee.

How to compare two real offers

  1. Put the contract’s expected profit, your state and your expenses into the 1099 tax calculator.
  2. Put the salary into the US paycheck calculator to see the W-2 take-home.
  3. Add what the W-2 offer pays on top: the employer’s share of the health premium, the 401(k) match and the paid days off.
  4. Divide by the hours you’ll really bill.

To check what the job pays in the first place, see our pay pages for software engineers in the US and web developers in the US, two jobs often done on contract, the salary calculator for other jobs, and the US country page for pay by state. Once you know your number, the salary negotiation script helps you ask for it. Working remotely for a client abroad is a different calculation: see global pay arbitrage.

Limits of this comparison

  • Every example is a single filer with the standard deduction and no other income, under 2026 federal rules. State tax comes from our state engine, which leaves out local taxes and any state rules written only for the self-employed.
  • The QBI deduction is simplified, and none is assumed above $201,750 of taxable income.
  • The benefit costs are BLS averages for full-time private-sector workers, not any one employer’s plan, and the 1,859 hours assume average paid leave.
  • This is information, not tax advice. Your own deductions, credits and filing status change the result.

How we treat official figures and our own calculations is explained in our methodology.

Sources

Air Traffic Controller

Stable demand

$148k US median

$78k to $216k

Certification

Commercial Pilot

Growing demand

$123k US median

$59k to $267k

Certification

Dentist

Growing demand

$171k US median

$86k to $320k

Doctorate

Free tool

Is your pay where it should be?

Pick your job, country and experience level and see the market range in seconds.

Open the salary calculator